Musician Frazer Barry argues that South Africans should not be afraid to examine their roots or ask difficult questions about them as he shared some of his family history during his address as guest speaker at the Partners in Agri Land Solutions (PALS) annual general meeting in Ceres.
By Talitha Janse van Vuuren, multimedia editor at African Farming
In 1994, 19-year-old Frazer Barry and a friend broke into a holiday home in Kleinmond, convinced they were taking something back after generations of dispossession. He was a member of the ANC Youth League in Kleinmond and, in his own words, he was “incredibly eager to use force to reclaim our land”.
His family’s history made the anger personal.
He grew up hearing how his ancestors had been treated and seeing what that history had done to his grandparents. He saw holiday homes standing empty in the white neighbourhoods, built on land he regarded as belonging to his Khoekhoen ancestors. His more immediate ancestors had lost land under the Group Areas Act.
So one night he and a friend decided they were going to take something back. “My friend and I crossed the road, picked out a house, broke in, and proceeded to carry out basically every single thing we could find inside.” They took cutlery, bedding, televisions, CD and DVD players, towels and whatever else they could carry.
“It felt like sweet revenge.”
More than three decades later, he has a different perspective: “Today, I know that two wrongs don’t make a right.”
Barry, a musician, theatre performer, and television and radio presenter, told this story during his address at the PALS annual general meeting in Ceres on 27 August. The theme of the gathering was “Honouring our Roots. Forward with Purpose”, and Barry used his own roots – complicated, painful and deeply South African – to ask what moving forward actually means.
He recalled the message coming from within the ANC at the time, articulated by Nelson Mandela, that violence would not be the route forward. Barry said resistance would have followed, innocent blood would have been shed and one act of violence would simply have produced another.
“We cannot repay blood with blood; otherwise, the cycle will never end.”
Also read: The land question is not black and white

A family history tied to the land
Barry’s family story does not fit comfortably into a simple racial box.
On his mother’s side, he has traced his ancestry to an Afrikaans-speaking Scotsman married to a Dutch woman, and to a Sri Lankan enslaved woman who married a Khoekhoen man. On his father’s side, he spoke of a Jewish great-grandfather who came from St Helena Bay and a great-grandmother with Indo-Javanese and Khoekhoen ancestry.
His Scottish-Dutch grandmother fell in love with and married his grandfather, a “Coloured” man with Khoekhoen, Indo and Scottish ancestry. Barry said she was one of nine sisters, all of whom married across the colour divide and relinquished their “white” status and the privileges attached to it.
His great-grandfather lost his farm. His grandfathers, he said, were subjected to the dopstelsel, under which farmworkers were partly paid in alcohol. Barry described one grandfather receiving a bottle of wine before starting work in the morning, another at lunchtime and a final bottle in the evening.
Yet the grandfather Barry remembers cannot be reduced to what was done to him. At 16, he founded the town’s rugby club and bought the church’s first organ. Music became part of family life – his sons played guitar and his daughters sang. Barry remembers his grandparents inviting homeless people to eat at their table and his grandfather giving his best shirts away.
It is an uncomfortable family history because several things are true at once. There was dispossession, poverty and damage that continued into the next generation. There was also family, generosity, music, resistance and people who refused to be defined entirely by their circumstances.
Barry does not argue that South Africans should forget any of it. His argument is almost the opposite: “Do not be afraid of our roots.”
Also watch: What five words can teach us about the land
More questions, fewer quick answers
Knowing where South Africans come from should make the country’s conversations more considered, not less, Barry said.
“Perhaps this is precisely the aspect of the conversation that is needed nationally: questions rather than answers.”
He argued that answers are too easily offered as opinions before people have properly thought through the issues in front of them.
“Questions provide balance to the conversation and dialogue, as well as the necessary in-depth exploration of possibilities.”
He illustrated the point with an analogy: A group of people can agree on their destination. That is the easy part. Immediately afterwards come the difficult questions: Which route? How long will it take? Who drives? Does everyone leave together? Where will they stop? What will the weather be like? It is in answering such questions where the work of actually moving forward begins.
For agriculture, where questions of land, ownership and history remain close to the surface, Barry’s own story offers no neat formula for resolving them.
Perhaps that was the point.
The 19-year-old who once believed taking possessions from somebody else’s house was a way of taking something back is now willing to tell that story publicly, without pretending the anger behind it didn’t exist. He simply draws a different lesson from it now: “Two wrongs don’t make a right.”
















































