When I joined the wildlife industry a few years ago, I was warned not to criticise the government openly for fear of victimisation. I took those words seriously, until I realised that my silence had earned me nothing, while those who kept me quiet had gained everything. The buck stops here. This letter marks the beginning of many more, and if speaking out costs me my life, so be it. I refuse to take my silence to the grave.
By Makena Ngoato, an experienced licensed hunting outfitter and wildlife trader specialising in sustainable wildlife management solutions
Transformation in the wildlife sector
I am deeply disappointed in how you and your government have handled transformation in the wildlife sector. When you became President, I was hopeful that you would make this a priority, given that you are the most successful Black game farmer in South Africa. I was wrong. You seem to enjoy the benefits alone, forgetting the many Black South Africans who aspire to participate meaningfully in this industry.
I have previously written to your office about the failures of land affairs, particularly in the North West province. I am a licensed professional hunter and outfitter in five provinces, yet without government intervention, this industry will remain white-dominated, with only a few Black politicians benefiting.
Also read: Rethinking commercial hunting: Misconceptions, realities and the future for black hunters
More than donations and employment
Recently, when the French government considered banning trophy imports, the wildlife industry circulated requests for African politicians to sign statements claiming that hunting benefits Africans. I believe your government participated in that deception. Hunting does not benefit Africans if all it offers is donations. We, Black professional hunters, need land to operate from and opportunities to earn a living, create jobs and contribute to GDP. We cannot remain employees forever. We deserve to sit at the table with clients and drive them ourselves, not ride in the back of bakkies like cargo on cold winter mornings.
Leaders who no longer serve their people
History warns us of the danger of leaders who look like us but no longer serve us. There is an old political fable about a young donkey captured by a pride of lions. Instead of killing him, the lions raised him, praised him and reconditioned his mind until he truly believed he was a lion himself. When he was fully brainwashed, they sent him back to his own herd. Because the other donkeys saw him as one of their own, they trusted him and did not run – allowing him to lead them straight into the lions’ den for slaughter. Likewise, too many politicians enter the system promising to represent the people, only to be consumed by power. They return during elections wearing our colours and speaking our language, but they serve the interests that feed them – not the people who trusted them.
Also read: Bird hunters: An undeniable solution for crop and grain farmers
Land access remains a barrier
It is disheartening that every time I apply for a game farm, I am told, “Good luck, comrades are already eyeing it.” Some even boast, “I fought in exile; it’s payback time.” If you doubt this, ask Thoko Didiza (the former Minister of Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.). She once had to intervene in the allocation of a farm called Woodstock in the North West province.
Mr President, your government has no clear plan to transform this industry. The Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment (DFFE) is making progress, but Land Affairs is failing to support it. Even the application forms for land leases exclude those seeking land for wildlife operations. During her tenure as Minister of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment, Minister Barbara Creecy introduced a Game Meat Strategy, but it seems to have vanished with her departure.

Efforts to make the industry more inclusive
It is unacceptable that we continue to rely on white stakeholders to solve problems they have no genuine interest in addressing. The moment we mention “land”, they disengage completely. Not long ago, I engaged with Safari Club International (SCI), requesting its support in developing Black professional hunters in South Africa to make the industry more inclusive. While the international office in the United States welcomed the idea, the local South African office derailed the entire initiative, forcing me to withdraw my application. I will soon write an article about that experience as well.
Also read: Opinion: Transformation in the wildlife sector cannot happen without a collective will
Transformation must become action
Mr President, transformation cannot remain a slogan. It must become action. The wildlife economy will never be inclusive until Black professionals are empowered not just to work in it – but to own, lead and shape it.
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of African Farming, its publisher, editors, employees, affiliates or associated partners.
















































